The Best Coaches Never Think They've Arrived
By Ruthie Pérez Slingerland, MCC; Jamie Slingerland, MCC; and David Whitehead | Catalyst Coach Academy
Years of experience do not mean you are still getting better. Here is how to check.
Coaching gets easier with time. That is good news. It can also be a problem.
You have your credential. You have plenty of hours. Clients tell their friends about you. But when sessions start to feel easy, many coaches quietly stop growing. We see this a lot with ACC and PCC coaches.
Here is a simple test. Can you guess where a session is going by minute ten? If so, you may have stopped listening for what could surprise you.
When Experience Gets in the Way
Clients rarely complain. They just get a good session instead of one that changes something.
The freeze that new coaches feel in the room does not go away with time. In experienced coaches, it just hides behind smooth sessions.
Here are four signs it is happening to you:
- You love your favorite questions. You keep asking what has always worked, and you stop really listening.
- You trust your gut too much. You steer clients toward your answer instead of theirs.
- You jump in to fix things. Your client loses the chance to find their own next step.
- You stay comfortable. You stop asking whether your own biases are getting in the way.
A good first step is knowing your own habits. Look closely at your strengths, blind spots, and growth edges as a coach.
People often ask, "How long have you been coaching?" That only tells you about time. A better question is: "What are you still learning as you coach?"
What a Catalyst Does
Think of a client in the middle of a hard decision. Halfway through a sentence, they stop. You have a question ready. It has worked a hundred times.
A coach who thinks they have arrived asks it right away. A coach who is still learning waits and notices the pause. Is the client unsure? Relieved? Still working out a thought? Wait three seconds. Often the client finishes the sentence with something they did not know they thought.
The coach did not use a new tool. They let go of a good question and paid attention to the person.
A catalyst helps the client make a change. The coach does not need to look smart.
Three Habits That Keep You Growing
1. Get a second set of ears.Mentor coaching means a skilled MCC coach listens to a real session and gives you feedback based on the ICF competencies. It helps you earn your credential. It helps just as much after you have it. Bring the session you are least proud of. That is where you will learn the most.
2. Take two minutes after every session. Before you check email, ask yourself:
Where did I follow my client, and where did I steer?
Write down one moment of each. Then ask: What was I protecting when I steered? After ten sessions, read your notes. You will see a pattern. The session is where you practice. The replay is where you learn.
3. Go back to the basics. Each quarter, pick one ICF competency and read it again. Start with demonstrating ethical practice and embodying a coaching mindset. Ask what it means to you now, not the day you learned it.
Your Next Step
The credential is a checkpoint. It is not a finish line.
If sessions have started to feel easy, take that seriously. Two ways to start:
- Book a discovery call to talk about where you are and what comes next.
- Ask about mentor coaching and get an MCC's ear on a real session.